I htought you might enjoy reading this nice article about Adnrew's new Play. Hope you enjoy reading it and their is a very nice ph of Adnrew on the page too.
Andrew McCarthy, known to film audiences for his roles in Pretty in Pink, St. Elmo's Fire and Weekend at Bernie's, has a stage background that includes Eugene O'Neill's Long Day's Journey into Night.
Gary Griffin directs Andrew McCarthy in 'Moon for the Misbegotten.' A production that unites Andrew McCarthy, a member of the 1980s "Brat Pack," with Gary Griffin, a director known for his recent accomplishments in musical theater, to perform an emotional play set in the 1920s is quite an undertaking. That the production will be staged in the modern setting of the Berlind stage of McCarter Theatre in Princeton makes it even more unique. While the production might be characterized as ambitious, challenging even, it is certainly not misbegotten. But the characters in McCarter's production of Eugene O'Neill's A Moon for the Misbegotten most definitely are, at least in some ways. The play runs from Jan. 13 to Feb. 19. Despite the sometimes tragic undertones throughout the play (it reintroduces Jamie Tyrone, a main character in O'Neill's Pulitzer Prize-winning A Long Day's Journey into Night, which was inspired by O'Neill's real-life alcoholic older brother), director Gary Griffin's production is infused with expectation. "We've all tried to find what they hope for so there's not a defeatist sense," Mr. Griffin says of the cast's approach to embodying the complicated characters. "We approach it with an underlying hope." The play takes place over the course of a single evening, telling the story of Jamie Tyrone and his two tenant farmers, Phil Hogan and his daughter, Josie. The story focuses on relationships on the bond between Phil and Josie, and the companionship that develops between Jamie, an alcoholic, and Josie, an overweight and lonely single woman. It is a story of love and forgiveness, of suffering and survival. Although the haunting tale is not one of Eugene O'Neill's best-known works, Mr. Griffin, 45, has dreamed of directing it since he first read it in his 20s. "It's an essential play," he says. "It speaks volumes about our experiences as human beings. It's about some simple truths about loneliness. It's about survival." While A Moon for the Misbegotten and A Long Day's Journey into Night share the character of Jamie Tyrone, played by Mr. McCarthy, Mr. Griffin insists that they are two distinct pieces with very different goals. And, although A Moon for the Misbegotten is often described as contradictory, Mr. Griffin doesn't see it that way. "It's balanced, more than contradictory," he says. "I don't think O'Neill is telling you how to feel. It's open to the audience. I think he was more concerned about telling the story. I don't think he had an agenda." Just as the play is open to the audience, Mr. Griffin wanted a set equally as open and inviting. While most stagings of A Moon for the Misbegotten take place on the porch in front of the Hogan home, Mr. Griffin gave the house a real presence in the production, and the actors are right at home, freely moving among its rooms and the porch. Eugene Lee, the Tony Award-winning set designer for the Broadway musical Wicked, designed the open-walled house that now occupies the Berlind stage. In order to accommodate the house, the front rows of seats were repositioned to surround the porch. The move brings with it the added benefit of a theater-in-the-round ambience, making the audience at home with the characters. "I wanted the house to be a character in the piece," Mr. Griffin says. "There's a whole life going on in this home inside and outside. I wanted to really keep it alive." The house is not the only inanimate character playing a major role in the production the moon itself, title billing notwithstanding, is of paramount importance. "The moon is a character, too, this presence of truth," he continues, explaining that much of O'Neill's dialogue centers around the moon. Ultimately an omniscient presence in the story, the moon leads the characters, and the audience, to reflect on what it truly means to come into the light. With the set and lighting harmonizing to create an intimate and embracing atmosphere on the Berlind stage, Mr. Griffin is thrilled to revisit the theater after his first experience on the stage, with the critically acclaimed musical My Fair Lady in 2004. "I love the Berlind stage," he says. "It's an intimate theater. There's something warm about it." Mr. Griffin wasn't the only one revisiting his past in the staging of A Moon for the Misbegotten. In 1999, Mr. McCarthy played the role of Jamie Tyrone in the Hartford Stage's production of A Long Day's Journey into Night. Grateful for the chance few actors ever have to revisit a challenging role he says he had always hoped to play Jamie Tyrone in another production of A Long Day's Journey into Night. The chance to play an older version of the misbegotten character with the added experience of years is "even better," he says. "He's the same guy," Mr. McCarthy says. "It's a wonderful opportunity. It's sort of like seeing an old friend again." While the character was an old friend, the other two lead actors Kathleen McNenny and Jack Willis were complete strangers, to Mr. McCarthy and to each other, prior to beginning rehearsals. And yet, Mr. Griffin says, the actors quickly bonded and adopted the relationship dynamics of the play, with a father-daughter relationship forming quickly between Mr. Willis and Ms. McNenny. "Just by virtue of doing it you start to find that same dynamic," Mr. Griffin says. "It's just that gripping for six hours a day. The important thing is to find the way the play works best for these actors." Just as coming back to the play 20 years after first encountering it at as a college student has offered Mr. Griffin a new perspective on the piece. "It's fresher than I had understood," he says. His production likewise offers a new perspective not only on A Moon for the Misbegotten, but on playwright Eugene O'Neill. "The piece really is about the survival of the spirit in a very, very essential way," he says. A Moon for the Misbegotten plays at the Berlind Theatre, McCarter Theatre Center, 91 University Place, Princeton, Jan. 13-Feb. 19. Performances: Tues.-Thurs. 7:30 p.m.; Fri. 8 p.m.; Sat. 3, 8 p.m.; Sun. 2 p.m. Tickets cost $28-$48, $10 students. For information, call (609) 258-2787. On the Web: www.mccarter.org
er..... that line in this article "he is separated from his wife" that just means geographically, right? not like divorced?
they really coulda phrased that better!
McCarthy growing into great O'Neill roles
Actor favors theater over filmland Friday, January 13, 2006
BY PETER FILICHIAStar-Ledger Staff
NEW JERSEY STAGE
He smiles wanly as he says it, but he puts enough feeling in the statement to show that he means it. "I am not nostalgic about my past," says Andrew McCarthy.
That's why McCarthy, still remembered for his "Brat Pack" days in '80s Hollywood, isn't waiting around for another "Weekend at Bernie's" sequel. Instead, he's continuing his quest to be a serious dramatic actor by opening on Friday in Eugene O'Neill's 1943 classic, "A Moon for the Misbegotten," at the McCarter Theatre Center's Berlind stage in Princeton.
The irony is that he's playing Jamie Tyrone, a beleaguered actor turned drunk. There was a time when McCarthy, 43, could have fit that description. Though he now doesn't revisit the subject, he has, over the years, talked about his battle with alcoholism while shooting such films as "St. Elmo's Fire" in 1985 and "Pretty in Pink" a year later. After successfully completing a detox program in 1992, he's maintained his sobriety.
En route, McCarthy has dabbled in films and television, but has concentrated more on stage roles. On Broadway in 1999, he played the jazz musician's son in "Side Man," and the supercilious co-worker in Neil LaBute's "Fat Pig" off-Broadway in 2004. He's done a good deal of regional work in-between -- "doing roles I've really wanted to play, like Tom in 'The Glass Menagerie' at American Repertory Theatre" (in Cambridge, Mass., in 2001).
McCarthy already played Jamie Tyrone, seven years ago at Hartford Stage in Connecticut -- but in a completely different play. In 1940, O'Neill wrote a younger Jamie Tyrone, a character based on his brother James, in "Long Day's Journey into Night."
"In 'Long Day's Journey,' Jamie is shown 10 years earlier, when he believes he's going to have a career on stage. In 'A Moon for the Misbegotten,'" McCarthy says of O'Neill's final work, "we see it hasn't been a pretty 10 years." Then he adds, with a self-deprecating laugh, "Hopefully, I haven't gone down as far as Jamie has."
McCarthy, a New York resident, admits he wasn't especially willing to travel out of town to perform a play. (He is separated from his wife of six years, actress Carol Schneider. Their son, Sam, is 3.) Yet being in New Jersey is somewhat nostalgic because he is a Westfield native and made his first stage appearance at the Pingry School, then in Elizabeth.
"It was as the Artful Dodger in 'Oliver!'," he says. "I was cut from the basketball team in the 10th grade and my mother said, 'Try out for the play.' I didn't want to, but I did."
He attended New York University for two years. "I didn't drop out," he says, "I was kicked out. I went to the acting classes, but I didn't really go to my other classes.
"Then a friend told me about a movie being cast that was looking for '18, vulnerable and sensitive,' and I went, 'That's me.' I went up with 500 other vulnerable and sensitive kids. About 10 auditions later, I was in Chicago doing love scenes with Jacqueline Bisset in a movie called 'Class.' I don't even honestly remember if I told my parents I was kicked out of school. I said, 'You know, I got this part, and I'm going to go do it in Chicago.' It was lucky."
Though he doesn't express much fondness for the films he made, he turned on a television about six months ago and was pleasantly surprised.
"The sound came on before the picture," he says, "and I went, 'Who's that? I know this! Oh, that's me! That's my voice!' And it was 'Heaven Help Us' (1985), which is by far the nicest movie I did in that early time period. I watched a little of it, but I would never really sit and watch those old pictures."
He doesn't seek out the old gang, either.
"I live in New York, and they're out there," he says. "Hollywood's a funny place. It's very intoxicating when you're hot, and when you're working, it's fun, you're making money. I never understood when people said they were bored on a set, I always found it fascinating, with little mini-dramas all over. It's a carnival with circus people. My career would be different if I lived in Los Angeles. When you're doing a play, you're so far off the Hollywood radar."
Instead, he's concentrating on a list of stage roles he'd like to do.
"Fagin in 'Oliver!' is one. And I'm looking forward to doing 'Long Day's Journey' again, too," he says. "But when I'm old enough to play the father."
Hello. I saw A Moon Over Misbegotten last night. What a great play. Andrew was fabulous as were the other actors. If you have the chance this is a definate must see. I would definately see it again if given the opportunity. I sat in the very front row (which was only 3 feet from the stage) at the McCarter Theatre. We were so close you could see the white of his eyes.
Aaah lucky, Kathy! i'm in the UK, so unless the rumours bout AM doing exonerated for one week in the west end are true, i'm not likely to get the opportunity.
i did see Rob Lowe in a few good men, front row centre.
Kathy you are so lucky.For those of us out here in the hinterlands it is so frustrating. That is why we want him to get back to making films so we get a chance to see him.
Can you think of some way we can get a copy of the reviews ?Those newpaper articles had names but no city or addresses. I would love to see the reviews. Keep in touch Kathy.
Wish i could see Andrew in a play would really love to.. Please keep us informed if he does indeed come to the UK.. I'll be there in a flash to see him..
Andrew McCarthy, known to film audiences for his roles in Pretty in Pink, St. Elmo's Fire and Weekend at Bernie's, has a stage background that includes Eugene O'Neill's Long Day's Journey into Night.
Gary Griffin directs Andrew McCarthy in 'Moon for the Misbegotten.'
A production that unites Andrew McCarthy, a member of the 1980s "Brat Pack," with Gary Griffin, a director known for his recent accomplishments in musical theater, to perform an emotional play set in the 1920s is quite an undertaking. That the production will be staged in the modern setting of the Berlind stage of McCarter Theatre in Princeton makes it even more unique. While the production might be characterized as ambitious, challenging even, it is certainly not misbegotten. But the characters in McCarter's production of Eugene O'Neill's A Moon for the Misbegotten most definitely are, at least in some ways. The play runs from Jan. 13 to Feb. 19. Despite the sometimes tragic undertones throughout the play (it reintroduces Jamie Tyrone, a main character in O'Neill's Pulitzer Prize-winning A Long Day's Journey into Night, which was inspired by O'Neill's real-life alcoholic older brother), director Gary Griffin's production is infused with expectation. "We've all tried to find what they hope for so there's not a defeatist sense," Mr. Griffin says of the cast's approach to embodying the complicated characters. "We approach it with an underlying hope." The play takes place over the course of a single evening, telling the story of Jamie Tyrone and his two tenant farmers, Phil Hogan and his daughter, Josie. The story focuses on relationships on the bond between Phil and Josie, and the companionship that develops between Jamie, an alcoholic, and Josie, an overweight and lonely single woman. It is a story of love and forgiveness, of suffering and survival. Although the haunting tale is not one of Eugene O'Neill's best-known works, Mr. Griffin, 45, has dreamed of directing it since he first read it in his 20s. "It's an essential play," he says. "It speaks volumes about our experiences as human beings. It's about some simple truths about loneliness. It's about survival." While A Moon for the Misbegotten and A Long Day's Journey into Night share the character of Jamie Tyrone, played by Mr. McCarthy, Mr. Griffin insists that they are two distinct pieces with very different goals. And, although A Moon for the Misbegotten is often described as contradictory, Mr. Griffin doesn't see it that way. "It's balanced, more than contradictory," he says. "I don't think O'Neill is telling you how to feel. It's open to the audience. I think he was more concerned about telling the story. I don't think he had an agenda." Just as the play is open to the audience, Mr. Griffin wanted a set equally as open and inviting. While most stagings of A Moon for the Misbegotten take place on the porch in front of the Hogan home, Mr. Griffin gave the house a real presence in the production, and the actors are right at home, freely moving among its rooms and the porch. Eugene Lee, the Tony Award-winning set designer for the Broadway musical Wicked, designed the open-walled house that now occupies the Berlind stage. In order to accommodate the house, the front rows of seats were repositioned to surround the porch. The move brings with it the added benefit of a theater-in-the-round ambience, making the audience at home with the characters. "I wanted the house to be a character in the piece," Mr. Griffin says. "There's a whole life going on in this home inside and outside. I wanted to really keep it alive." The house is not the only inanimate character playing a major role in the production the moon itself, title billing notwithstanding, is of paramount importance. "The moon is a character, too, this presence of truth," he continues, explaining that much of O'Neill's dialogue centers around the moon. Ultimately an omniscient presence in the story, the moon leads the characters, and the audience, to reflect on what it truly means to come into the light. With the set and lighting harmonizing to create an intimate and embracing atmosphere on the Berlind stage, Mr. Griffin is thrilled to revisit the theater after his first experience on the stage, with the critically acclaimed musical My Fair Lady in 2004. "I love the Berlind stage," he says. "It's an intimate theater. There's something warm about it." Mr. Griffin wasn't the only one revisiting his past in the staging of A Moon for the Misbegotten. In 1999, Mr. McCarthy played the role of Jamie Tyrone in the Hartford Stage's production of A Long Day's Journey into Night. Grateful for the chance few actors ever have to revisit a challenging role he says he had always hoped to play Jamie Tyrone in another production of A Long Day's Journey into Night. The chance to play an older version of the misbegotten character with the added experience of years is "even better," he says. "He's the same guy," Mr. McCarthy says. "It's a wonderful opportunity. It's sort of like seeing an old friend again." While the character was an old friend, the other two lead actors Kathleen McNenny and Jack Willis were complete strangers, to Mr. McCarthy and to each other, prior to beginning rehearsals. And yet, Mr. Griffin says, the actors quickly bonded and adopted the relationship dynamics of the play, with a father-daughter relationship forming quickly between Mr. Willis and Ms. McNenny. "Just by virtue of doing it you start to find that same dynamic," Mr. Griffin says. "It's just that gripping for six hours a day. The important thing is to find the way the play works best for these actors." Just as coming back to the play 20 years after first encountering it at as a college student has offered Mr. Griffin a new perspective on the piece. "It's fresher than I had understood," he says. His production likewise offers a new perspective not only on A Moon for the Misbegotten, but on playwright Eugene O'Neill. "The piece really is about the survival of the spirit in a very, very essential way," he says. A Moon for the Misbegotten plays at the Berlind Theatre, McCarter Theatre Center, 91 University Place, Princeton, Jan. 13-Feb. 19. Performances: Tues.-Thurs. 7:30 p.m.; Fri. 8 p.m.; Sat. 3, 8 p.m.; Sun. 2 p.m. Tickets cost $28-$48, $10 students. For information, call (609) 258-2787. On the Web: www.mccarter.org
But McCarter production of O'Neill classic is still worthy of its place in the firmament Monday, January 23, 2006
BY PETER FILICHIAStar-Ledger Staff
NEW JERSEY STAGE
It's not "A Moon for the Misbegotten" at the McCarter Theatre Center, but "McMoon for the Misbegotten."
The big, forceful Eugene O'Neill classic isn't being staged at the Princeton company's larger Matthews Theatre, as one would expect. It's at the Berlind Theatre, which has fewer than a third as many seats, and less than half the stage space.
While the play gains something in intimacy, it loses something in raw power, too.
The director, Gary Griffin, is the man who miniaturized "My Fair Lady" here a couple of seasons ago. There he used using 10 performers instead of the original 48. Granted, O'Neill's 1943 play only has a cast of five, but most of them are supposed to be bigger than life. First and foremost, there's Josie Hogan, who could be called Daddy's Big Girl, for this "great, ugly cow" is Phil Hogan's favorite child. (The other three kids, predictably enough, are sons.)
If Mike Hogan, the only son shown in the play, is characteristic of the others, one can understand why Phil doesn't take to them. Mike may not be scared of his own shadow, but he's certainly frightened of Phil's. Meanwhile, Josie has her father's irascibility, earthiness and brute strength -- qualities to which Phil can relate.
Phil and Josie are tenant farmers who want to purchase the land they've worked. But will their landlord instead sell to T. Stedman Harder, the fat cat who can pay a bigger price? There's only one thing to do, Phil reasons, and that's to have Josie seduce that landlord.
He's James Tyrone Jr., the same character from O'Neill's masterpiece, "Long Day's Journey into Night." Here, though, he's 10 years older, and thousands of nights drunker. Nevertheless, James and Josie do have a great deal of mutual admiration, though both aren't the types to blatantly express their feelings. In this nearly three-hour script, they play a carefully calibrated set of mind games. Will either James or Josie ever find the flat-out gumption to say "I love you"? Perhaps they'll be too frightened to put their emotional cards on the table.
The legendary 1973 Broadway revival featured Colleen Dewhurst, the earth mother of all earth mothers, and the tall, imposing Jason Robards. Here, one must wonder if Griffin decided that in a small house, he needed smaller actors. Neither Kathleen McNenny's Josie nor Andrew McCarthy's James has the physical size one expects from these characters. What an audience gets is reminiscent of those ads for figurines seen in magazines: "Shown actual size."
Short of steroids, there's nothing these two can do about that. But they do work nicely together. No matter what anyone thinks of McCarthy from his Hollywood days, he's giving a solid and honest performance, especially when James talks about his relationship with his mother. McNenny effectively masks her great pain at committing a woman's worst sin in those days: She isn't attractive.
Though Jack Willis would seem to only need a good deal of bluster and blarney to play Phil, the character has an important scene where he must come clean to Josie. It's one of the production's best moments.
As Mike, Peter Scanavino gets the play off to a good start in the scene where he leaves home. However, Jeremiah Wiggins seems clichιd as Harder, and settles for making him an effete impudent snob. Ultimately, this may not be a full "Moon," but it's at least a three-quarter one.
A Moon for the Misbegotten (McCarter Theater Center, Princeton, N.J., 423 seats, $48 top)
A McCarter Theater Center presentation of a play in two acts by Eugene O'Neill. Directed by Gary Griffin.
Josie Hogan - Kathleen McNenny Phil Hogan - Jack Willis James Tyrone Jr. - Andrew McCarthy Mike Hogan - Peter Scanavino T. Stedman Harder - Jeremiah Wiggins
function decimal(weekbox){ var number = weekbox; if (number.indexOf('.')==-1){ number = number + '.0'; }else{ number=number; } document.write('$' + number); }
view: full chart box office news film openingsThere's no present or future -- only the past, happening over and over again -- now." The past, with its entourage of guilt and regret, is Eugene O'Neill's great subject. It is also the challenge of reviving a classic, especially one with a history of luminous productions. Gary Griffin and his cast more than meet this challenge in a moving, low-key "A Moon for the Misbegotten," O'Neill's last and arguably best play.
O'Neill took a plot so familiar it sounds like a joke -- Broadway dandy meets farmer's daughter -- and transformed it into a meditation on disappointment.
Jim Tyrone (Andrew McCarthy), awash in self-loathing, medicates his existential "heebie-jeebies" with whiskey and whores. Earth mother Josie (Kathleen McNenny), a big, proud, rough woman, defends herself against loneliness with manufactured gossip that she is the town slut. Her cunning, brutal father, Phil Hogan (Jack Willis), who has driven his three sons away from their hardscrabble farm, masks his tenderness for his daughter with tough talk.
In a plot full of scheming -- for love, for money, for revenge -- there is always "a trick behind the trick"; we think we're in on the plans, only to be surprised by yet another ploy. What starts as farce shades into tragedy; powerful revelations and heart-wrenching last chances fill a moonlit second-act duet.
The three characters, filled with complex self-contradictions, require actors who can convey their wounded humanity with subtlety and charm. Phil Hogan, often treated as a minor character, is major here, and Willis is a shrewd, apelike and violent Phil; the actor can play a man play-acting so convincingly that we're never quite sure what we're watching.
Jim tells Josie they "belong to the same club. We can kid the world, but we can't fool ourselves." And so they kid us, until we see through the bluff. Seeing into the truth of things is not only the plot and the structure of the play, it describes the experience of watching it. And this requires acting within acting.
McNenny amply fills the part of Josie, one of American dramatic literature's great female roles, despite her modest size. She is both lovely and plain, managing to show us the crucial girlish sweetness under the defensive swagger and grubbiness.
McCarthy crafts a Jim Tyrone who is, at first, so light on his feet he seems to dance while his fingers flicker in nervous, graceful gestures. Then his flair crumbles to ashes and despair.
Visually, the production is flawed. The puzzling set is especially surprising, since the McCarter is known for spectacular set designs. But the Hogan shanty is inappropriately huge, with little to suggest poverty or the ramshackle quality of their lives. Inexplicably, people sometimes walk through the invisible front wall, sometimes go around and use the door. The immense upstage wall is unreadable: Is it bleached-out tree bark? A gigantic wrinkled sheet?
And, in a play about moonlight, the lighting seems understated and untheatrical. Strict naturalism undermines the passion, and for O'Neill, passion is always the point.
Sets, Eugene Lee; costumes, Jess Goldstein; lighting, Jane Cox; sound, Andre Pluess, Ben Sussman; fight director, J. Steven White; production stage manager, Cheryl Mintz. Opened Jan. 20, 2006; reviewed Jan. 21; runs through Feb. 19, 2006. Running time: 2 HOURS, 40 MIN.
Since its first performance almost a half-century ago, Eugene O'Neill's "A Moon for the Misbegotten" has drawn mixed reactions.
Critics have called it everything from "a neglected masterpiece" to "a tedious harangue," and its current revival at McCarter's Berlind Theatre probably will elicit equally diverse responses. On opening night, for example, there were fewer spectators after the intermission than before it.
This handsome production directed with relentless energy by Gary Griffin solves some of the problems inherent in the play, but it creates others, especially with its casting.
Notably in the first act, the cast of five tear into their roles with an energy and enthusiasm that is breathtaking. Rather than face the ire of O'Neill purists who would bemoan judicious pruning of the script, Griffin has opted to speed up the action and bring scenes into the auditorium where the lowest level of Eugene Lee's set sits like an overburdened shelf. A skeletal house, falling down or perhaps never finished, towers out of sight in front of a backdrop that looks like elephant hide. Although that sky can look impressive under some of Jane Cox's lighting designs, it gives the moon of the title short shrift in the last act.
This Connecticut pig farm is home to the Hogans, but T. Stedman Harder (Jeremiah Wiggins), a rich and snooty neighbor, wants to buy it so he can dispossess the Hogans, who let their pigs wander onto his estate. When youngest son Mike (Peter Scanavino) leaves because he can no longer stand his father Phil (Jack Willis), only Josie (Kathleen McNenny) remains at home. Josie and Phil delight in their perpetually argumentative relationship and plot how to save their rented farm from being sold out from under them by dissipated James Tyrone Jr. (Andrew McCarthy), their present landlord.
Willis, Wiggins and Scanavino are admirably suited to their roles and perform them commendably, but McNenny and McCarthy in the play's biggest roles have opposite and major problems.
She looks nothing like the character O'Neill describes or that her relatives refer to in derogatory terms. Putting her in baggy dresses and having her clomp around in bare, dirty feet do not change this attractive actress into the "great slut" or "cow" called for in the script. Her voice, however, is magnificent. She can invest her lines with bile or seductive richness; she weaves O'Neill's words into a magnificent tapestry, especially in the third act, which is a long, emotionally shifting love duet.
McCarthy is lithe and agile, moving with the grace of an elegant dancer in Jess Goldstein's natty costume. He looks totally believable as the actor who would be perfect as a romantic leading man. McCarthy's voice, however, is thin and monotonous, lacking color and variety, especially in that third act, where the traumatic story of his mother's death and his own degrading return to alcoholism explodes from him. Perhaps it's because director Griffin wants everything so fast that McCarthy's voice seems ineffective - or perhaps it's just too big a contrast with McNenny's richly nuanced delivery.
Like so many other productions of this problematic play, McCarter's is a mixed bag, but it offers a worthy attempt to resurrect a play rarely done.
"A Moon for the Misbegotten" will run through Feb. 19 at McCarter's Berlind Theatre, 91 University Place, Princeton, 7:30 p.m. Tuesdays-Thursdays and Sundays, 8 p.m. Fridays-Saturdays, 3 p.m. Saturdays and 2 p.m. Sundays, $28-$48. available. (609) 258-2787 or www.mccarter.org
At McCarter, tough love of 'Misbegotten' is deeply felt Toby Zinman For The Inquirer
From the early, short plays like The Emperor Jones to the late, long plays like A Long Day's Journey Into Night, Eugene O'Neill's great subject is regret - the might-have-been, the if-only, the too-late. In A Moon for the Misbegotten, his last play, the yearning and the remorse are intense, and McCarter Theatre's production of this American classic is deeply moving.
The hardscrabble farmer, Phil Hogan, and his big, voluptuous daughter, Josie, make a formidable pair: Both of them are tough, proud and audacious. She is known as the town slut, and her father is a slave-driving drunk whose three sons have run away from the mean life on their farm. We enjoy the Hogan blarney and mischief, their attack on Harder, their snobbish, rich neighbor, and we are touched by their rough love for each other.
Jim Tyrone, a Broadway dandy in spats and pinky ring, is their landlord and Phil's drinking pal. This is the same Jamie Tyrone we know from Long Day's Journey - a drunk and a squanderer with a taste for whores. Years of dissipation, his parents' deaths, and an incurable self-loathing have turned him into "a dead man walking slow behind his own coffin," as Josie says pityingly. It becomes clear that Jim and Josie love each other profoundly, although it takes them most of the play to be able to acknowledge that.
Phil Hogan always has "a trick behind the trick," and we watch layers of scheming pile up; we think we're in on the plans, only to be surprised by yet another layer and another ploy. What starts as farce shades into tragedy as the powerful revelations and heart-wrenching last chances create a second act duet of pathos and need.
The three characters, filled with complex self-contradictions, require three actors who can convey their wounded humanity with subtlety and charm.
Josie is one of the great female dramatic roles, and Kathleen McNenny is wonderfully earthy, managing to show us the crucial girlish sweetness under the defensive swagger and grubbiness. Jack Willis is a shrewd, apelike and violent Phil - an actor who can play a man playacting so convincingly that we're never quite sure what we're watching. Andrew McCarthy crafts a Jim Tyrone who is, at first, so light on his feet he seems to dance while his fingers flicker in nervous, graceful gestures, and then we watch this flair crumble to ashes and despair.
The only flawed aspect of the production is the set, and this is especially surprising since the McCarter is known for spectacular set designs. But the Hogan shanty is inappropriately huge, with very little to suggest poverty or the ramshackle quality of their lives. And sometimes people walk through the invisible front wall and sometimes they go around and use the door. Inexplicably, Josie can see the clock on the kitchen wall from the front yard. The immense upstage wall is unreadable; what are we looking at for nearly three hours - bleached-out tree bark? A gigantic wrinkled sheet?
Gary Griffin, who directed the current Broadway production of The Color Purple, directs this long, exposition-filled play with admirable naturalness and speed; O'Neill's dialogue is often clunky on the page, but here the delivery is human and intimate, and Griffin has found a way to let the play escape from the prison of "classic" back into living drama.
A Moon for the Misbegotten
Written by Eugene O'Neill, directed by Gary Griffin, sets by Eugene Lee, costumes by Jess Goldstein, lighting by Jane Cox, sound by Andrι Pluess and Ben Sussman, fight direction by J. Steven White. Produced by McCarter Theatre Company.
The cast: Andrew McCarthy (Jim Tyrone), Kathleen McNenny (Josie Hogan), Jack Willis (Phil Hogan), Peter Scanavino (Mike Hogan), Jeremiah Wiggins (T. Stedman Harder).
Playing at: McCarter Theatre Center, Berlind Theatre, 91 University Place, Princeton, through Feb. 19.
McCarter presents an intimate "Moon" Home News Tribune Online 01/26/06By C.W. WALKER CORRESPONDENT
To begin with, there's a house.
OAS_AD('Right3');
Because most of the action in Eugene O' Neill's "A Moon for the Misbegotten" takes place in the front yard of Hogan place, in most productions, all we usually see is the front porch.
But for the new show now on stage at the McCarter Theater Center's Berlind Theatre, award-winning set designer Eugene Lee has built the entire house. Cozy if a little rundown, the fully furnished rooms in the front fade away into a half constructed silhouette of bare beams — a tangible symbol of unfinished dreams.
Lee also has taken the front yard playing area and thrust it right out into the reconfigured first rows of seats, bringing the action closer to the audience. Add to this Jane Cox's lighting, so lush and burnished you can almost see the actual moonlight, and you have a play that's more intimate, accessible and inviting.
The same can be said for this "Moon" overall, although not everyone will appreciate making O'Neill warmer and a little fuzzier. The director, Gary Griffin, also was responsible for an essentialist, boutique version of "My Fair Lady" at McCarter a few seasons ago. Clearly, Griffin likes to think a little outside the box — and he's confident enough as a director to make it work, even if the risk-taking isn't a resounding success.
"Moon for the Misbegotten," which many consider a kind of epilogue to "Long Day's Journey Into Night," is a difficult play to watch and present. If it's done right, the emotions are so raw and the characters, when they drop their facades, are left so vulnerable, that it's almost too painful to witness.
Although there are five characters in all, only three really matter and casting them is a feat in itself. There's Mike Hogan, the Irish tenant farmer who's not quite the garrulous, uncaring drunk he pretends to be. He hides his needy attachment for his adult daughter, Josie, behind rough jokes and insults. Worse, he sends her out to seduce the landlord in order to save the farm, knowing full well what it will cost her emotionally. In a recent Broadway version, Hogan was played as a rascally leprechaun by Roy Dotrice. Here, however, Peter Scanavino gives us a big, blustery but quite fragile man, a portrayal reminiscent of Brian Dennehy's approach to James Tyrone Sr. in the 2003 Broadway production of "Long Day's Journey Into Night."
The landlord, of course, is James Tyrone Jr., modeled on O'Neill's real life brother, James, a self-loathing alcoholic who was confined to a sanitarium at the time "Moon" was written. Critics have judged this play O'Neill's benediction for his tragic, unlikable brother, and really, it's hard to see it as anything else. Andrew McCarthy, late of the Brat Pack movies, doesn't quite have the matinee-idol charisma we might expect for this role. But looking like a thin, pale wraith in spats, he does communicate the sense that James is really a walking dead man revived for only a few hours before he's consigned to his fate.
The character responsible for that revival is Josie Hogan, played by Kathleen McNenny. Part whore, part virgin, part earth-mother, Josie is O'Neill's fantasy of a perfect woman. She is also, as O'Neill himself admitted, impossible to cast.
Colleen Dewhurst, when she appeared opposite Jason Robards, came closest as no one has since. McNenny is no exception. She's really not right for the part. She's tall all right, but not even close to the homely, large breasted woman — the "ugly cow" — envisioned by O'Neill, and no amount of mussed hair or mud on her feet will change that.
Nevertheless, she has a lovely, heartfelt rapport with McCarthy, as well as tremendously long legs and large, expressive hands to pet, embrace and ultimately cradle him with.
Similarly, this production draws us in and cradles us as well. That may not please O'Neill purists, but it is, as Josie is for the failing Tyrone, good enough.
JASON TOWLEN Gannett News Service Andrew McCarthy takes a break on stage at the McCarter Theatre in Princeton, where he is starring in the theater's production of "A Moon for the Misbegotten.'
IF YOU GO "A Moon for the Misbegotten' will be performed through Feb. 19 at McCarter Theatre Center, 91 University Place, Princeton. Tickets are $28 to $48. Call (609) 258-2787 or visit www.mccarter.org
Saturday, January 21, 2006 By LAURIE GRANIERI Gannett New Jersey
Actors often speak about keeping a mental list of roles they yearn to play.
Andrew McCarthy's pet roles are rooted in the hallmark works of 20th-century American theater such as Tom Wingfield in Tennessee Williams' The Glass Menagerie, James Tyrone Jr. in Eugene O'Neill's Long Day's Journey Into Night and in O'Neill's final work, the semi-autobiographical A Moon for the Misbegotten.
McCarthy checks off Tyrone from his list when he stars this month in A Moon for the Misbegotten at Princeton's McCarter Theatre Center. Gary Griffin (Broadway's The Color Purple) directs.
"There are several plays I've wanted to do in my life . . . and this is one of them," says McCarthy, 43, who grew up in Westfield, Union County, and went on to become a member of Hollywood's Brat Pack in the 1980s, starring in such films as St. Elmo's Fire, Pretty in Pink and Weekend at Bernie's. Doing O'Neill and Williams is "sort of climbing a mountain for an actor, good mountains to have climbed. They change you as actors."
O'Neill's tragic Moon focuses on washed-up New York actor and braggart Jamie Tyrone, loosely based on O'Neill's brother. Tyrone, an alcoholic haunted by his mother's death, is the non-resident landlord of a farmhouse occupied by Josie Hogan (Kathleen McNenny) and her Irish-immigrant father, Phil (Jack Willis). The play, which originally ran on Broadway in 1957, four years after the author's death, takes place over the course of one boozy night as Josie and Jamie open up to each other.
"Doing O'Neill demands different things . . . a certain willingness to give it up that is very uncomfortable and unpleasant at times," McCarthy says.
He's revisiting the role of Jamie Tyrone after playing him in Long Day's Journey into Night in 1999. "But if the play's going to happen, people have to just do that. You're dealing with these sort of epic, big Greek emotions about love and hate and life and all these dreary topics."
But McCarthy seems more interested in exploring "dreary topics" than in dusting off memories about the old days on the set with Demi Moore and Molly Ringwald.
"I don't have much nostalgia for my past," he says. "Those movies . . . all that Brat Pack stuff, I mean, those were some good movies. I was glad to be part of them. It captured something for a generation . . . but I'm just sort of here now."
McCarthy has been all over the stage, in Broadway's Sideman and in off-Broadway productions of The Exonerated and Fat Pig. McCarthy recently made his directorial and writing debut with News for the Church, a short film based on a Frank O'Connor short story about a woman who confesses her sexual activity to a priest. In the fall, he appeared in several episodes of the Benjamin Bratt-Dennis Hopper TV series E-Ring.
He also is a seasoned traveler, though you probably won't find him holed up in a mammoth American chain hotel in Paris, wolfing down le Big Mac.
"I always came back a better person whenever I traveled," McCarthy says. "I came back having more empathy for people, because when you're alone and in a strange place and you speak nothing and don't know anyone, don't know where you're going to sleep, it's getting dark and you need people to help you, it's nice to put yourself in that position, because it brings out the best in one. We're always trying to find comfort and I think one of the reasons to travel is to step away from comfort."
Perhaps that's what O'Neill is about for McCarthy, what a thorny character such as Tyrone offers him: an opportunity to step outside of the comfort zone, a reason to empathize with a difficult personality.
"I don't think he's unlikable at all," McCarthy says of Jamie. "I think (he's) heroic in the sense of his relentless search to expose himself so he can be absolved in a certain way and I think that's a heroic journey, even though he has done some despicable things. When all is done, can we still be decent people and have done horrific things we're still ashamed of? That's his question: He's trying to figure out if he can, having done what he perceives to be these horrible things, still be a redeemable person."
These are epic questions, questions about faith and fate and demons, questions most of us -- including Tyrone -- might not face without a bottle of whiskey in one hand.
But McCarthy seems up to the task.
"It's all so open and raw and exposed," McCarthy says of the rehearsal process for Moon. "At a certain point, you're all on a life raft together . . . .
"This (role) came up. It's something I've wanted to do," he continues. "I was surprised it came up when it did. I said . . . "OK, am I ready for that? Well, ready or not, let's give it a try.' "
Review: A Moon for the Misbegotten February 02, 2006 By Gretchen C. Van Benthuysen
A Moon for the Misbegotten shoots out of the starting gate like a racehorse and doesn't stop for breath until the intermission 90 minutes later. Under Gary Griffin's direction, this Eugene O'Neill classic is a living, breathing, in-your-face production with a set (by Eugene Lee) jutting out into the house, entrances and exits made through the aisles, and lighting (by Jane Cox) that spills out onto several rows of the audience.
Kathleen McNenny as Josie and Jack Willis as her father, Phil Hogan, are loud and raucous as they trade insults and conspire against their rich new neighbor, T. Stedman Harder (Jeremiah Wiggins), and look forward to a visit from their old friend and landlord, James Tyrone Jr. (Andrew McCarthy). You don't have to be familiar with the tragic history of the O'Neill family to appreciate his plays, but it certainly doesn't hurt. Knowing that much of what we learn about Tyrone -- called Jamie -- was lifted from the life of the playwright's older brother makes Moon an even more sorrowful experience.
CM8ShowAd("Middle");
By the time Jamie enters, we know that his beloved mother has died and that he has been drinking himself into a blind stupor each day since, rarely stopping to eat. Yet it is still a shock when he appears. Although dapper-looking in a three-piece suit, straw hat, and spats (costumes by Jess Goldstein), he is so thin a strong wind could carry him away -- McNenny's Josie looks like she outweighs him by 20 pounds. They circle each other warily, as long-parted lovers do, before they spar, with Josie putting herself down and teasing Jamie about going back to the city and his "Broadway tarts."
As Jamie, McCarthy winces each time Josie talks about his wayward habits. Then he reaches out as if to physically stop her from calling herself a big, ugly lout. They love each other, but not in the same way. He has idealized Josie and where she lives: He comes to this broken-down Connecticut farm to see her -- almost as if she were an earth mother who can succor and comfort him -- because he knows she's pure, a virgin, unlike the women he's used to and uses to forget about life. And McNenny is a whirlwind: washing the floor, peeling potatoes, restlessly roaming the stage from one end to the other, and rarely stopping until Act III, when she holds Jamie close and gives him enough strength to make it to his grave.
As Phil Hogan, Willis would be at home in any pub in Ireland. His accent is good, he blusters and bubbles over when his intentions are doubted, and he spins "yarn" so well he could knit a sweater. As he throws Wiggins' Harder off his land, he warns, "When I get through with you, you'll think you're the king of England at an Irish wake."
Although they're dangerously close to being stereotypes today, the pain of each of O'Neill's characters feels as sharp now as it must have when he wrote the play nearly 60 years ago. Like most real Irish stories, it is the mix of humor and pathos that makes it so compelling to watch.
A Moon for the Misbegotten runs Jan. 13-Feb. 19 at the McCarter Theatre Center, 91 University Place, Princeton, N.J. Tickets: (609) 258-2787. Website: www.mccarter.org